Remote Lifting

Home › Forums › General Discussion › Remote Lifting

  • Creator
    Topic
  • #44546
    Al Myers
    Keymaster

      Sanjiv really provided us with a “thought provoking” website story regarding remote lifting in the USAWA. It seems some are really for it while others are much against the idea. Initially when this began a few years ago I thought it was a terrible direction for the USAWA to be going in. But then again, I’m “old school” regarding competition and feel face to face on the platform is what its all about – each lifter giving their best under identical lifting conditions with the same officials in the chairs. I also enjoyed the comradery of the fellow lifters which is something you don’t get lifting by yourself in your garage gym in a remote meet. However – I don’t want to be someone who resists change. I know we are in a world now where it’s all about playing video games in your basement by yourself against your “imaginary friends” on the internet. So maybe that’s what the majority of USAWA lifters want as well. Today when I was in the gym I tried to think of 3 good PROS for remote lifting and 3 CONS against remote lifting. I’m sure there are more but these are the ones I came up with.

      PROS
      1. Can compete if you can’t travel
      It gets costly going to meets and for some they just can’t afford it. Others it might be getting time off of work to travel. There are many reasons here – maybe just having other obligations on that weekend that conflict.

      2. Increases entries for promoters
      We are a small organization and often meets have few entries. Remote entries allow for a bigger “meet turnout”. If entry fees are charged this may help a meet promoter pay the bills for putting on the meet. Or just give the promoter more “bragging rights” about the great turnout!

      3. Gives more opportunities for the “mega lifters”
      Some lifters just love to enter meets! Remote lifting allows these lifters to lift in several meets in a month if they want. It gives them lots more opportunities to set records as well.

      CONS
      1. Decreases interest in traveling to meets
      Remote lifting allows competitive lifting to happen at home so what’s the point of traveling to meets?
      2. Lack of incentive for meet promoters
      With all these remote meets on the lifting schedule I don’t see why other promoters even want to sanction and put on meets. Just get the “gang together” on a Saturday afternoon and lift on some other promoter’s dime!

      3. Drug testing remote lifters is impossible
      We are a drug free organization and for years have had a great drug testing program. The responsibility of this program has been in the hands of the Drug Enforcement Director under the direction of the USAWA. It has always been the Meet Directors responsibility under the sanction to make sure that proper testing is done. How is this done with remote lifting by the meet director??? I would like to hear that answer. This reason alone is why I would never sanction a meet myself which included remote lifting. I could not turn a “blind eye” of allowing possible drug usage in a meet I was promoting. I wonder if the meet directors who allow remote lifting even think of this – or maybe they just don’t care.

      In wrapping all of this up, I do want to point out that the USAWA for many years has allowed remote lifting – It’s called the POSTAL MEET SERIES which is done under the direction of the Postal Meet Director and the USAWA. With remote lifting allowed it makes ALL MEETS postal meets so what’s the point of the Postal Series. If I was the Postal Meet Director I would have stepped down as the organization has made my duty obsolete.
      If everyone wants remote lifting I would have thought the sensible thing to do first would be to expand the number of meets in the Postal Series, maybe even up to one a month, instead of creating all this mess of pitting meets directors against each other with different feelings on the subject.

    Viewing 3 reply threads
    • Author
      Replies
      • #44552
        Jarrod Fobes
        Participant

          Al brings up some good points here. As someone who tried and failed to get an all-around club going in Colorado before the days of remote meets, I love the opportunities that come with remote competition. Quarterly postals just aren’t enough to keep people interested if they don’t live near an event. I agree that in person competition is the gold standard, but we are a small and scattered group. Removing the remote option will reduce a lot of competitions to two or three lifters. The thrill of face to face competition diminishes a bit when you only have one or two competitors.

          I think a reasonable compromise would be: no remote entries for prestige events such as nationals, multi-venue when it makes sense to do so, and more postals, with local clubs organizing their postal competitions to run as mini-meets.

          Last year was the first time I was able to make it to nationals and I’m hoping to make it yearly moving forward. But I have octogenarian parents in another state and a family business in yet another state, traveling to even one USAWA event a year is a strain. Removing remote events without postal options will greatly reduce how active I can be in the sport, and will make expanding our odd little group incredibly difficult. While I don’t believe in expansion at all costs, we should do everything we can to open up access to as many competitors as possible, provided we can do so without compromising our integrity.

        • #44560
          Al Myers
          Keymaster

            Hi Jarrod!

            I’m sure glad to see you competing in a lot of USAWA competitions! I sure understand why the remote entries have helped with this, as it allows a lifter to compete without having to take the entire weekend off to travel to a meet. That’s why I listed that reason as my PRO #1. I remember initially the main reason given for remote entries was that it would increase membership – well that theory really didn’t pan out. Membership has remained pretty much the same since remote entries began.

            I have always been a fan of our Postal Series for allowing lifters to lift at home without the need for travel, with these meets being directed by the USAWA instead of individual meet directors. The IAWAUK has a more robust Postal Series (they call it the Postal League) than we do. I have often in the past wondered if we should expand our postal series to offer the postal opportunities of the IAWAUK, but participation in our postal meets at that time didn’t seem to justify it. But now seeing all the entries in the postal meets as well as the interest with remote entries – expanding the Postal Series to more events per year would be well supported.

            The USAWA has the financial resources to conduct drug testing at a person’s home if that was decided on by the Drug Testing Director/USAWA EB – something an individual meet director would not do. It’s difficult enough for the organization to implement drug testing at a site meet when everyone is present. There’s evidence on the website that shows a lifter competing in a remote meet just months before a failed drug test at a site meet. This is an embarrassment to the USAWA. Yet the results are still up for that lifters remote entry and the lifters results are probably in the record list. I would be ashamed if I was that meet director! We should NOT BE SUPPORTING drug usage!

          • #44566
            Sanjiv Gupta
            Participant

              I am glad there is a little bit of discussion and back and forth going.

              I don’t think single venue live, multi-venue, remote, other will increase or decrease our membership significantly. Historically, we have bounced between 50 and 150 members with upticks based on enthusiastic meet promoters with ties to other strength sports communities and declines when people retire from competition, move, get busy with family or other strength sports or get upset and leave. All of these are valid reasons to leave USAWA, there are other All-Round Federations and 100’s of Powerlifting, Olympic Lifting, Grip Sport, Arm Wrestling, Highland Games (we could increase the list ad infinitum).

              National and World Championship are in a class of their own, despite the recent inclusion of record day lifts and questionable “National Records.” Athletes have shown a willingness to travel at least once a year.

              The other championships – President’s Cup, Grip, Team Lift, Club, OTSM, Heavy Lift have struggled to draw athletes. Quarterly postals have drawn 20-40% of the membership every quarter. No reason this could not expand to bi-monthly postals or monthly postals. The other 20ish meets are mostly at Clark’s Gym and allowing remote lifting should be up to the meet director. The athlete community can decide whether 1st place among 15 live and remote lifters is more meaningful than 1st place among 5 live lifters competing to the same standard, same officiating, same equipment, etc.

              While drug testing, ethics, integrity in competition would all favor live single venue, they are not jeopardized by remote athletes. We explored a video policy in 2024, drug test kits can be sent to any athlete at any time, and if people want to cheat with camera angles and fake weights that is on them.

            • #44568
              Jarrod Fobes
              Participant

                Hello Al! Always good to hear from you, we will have to meet in person one of these days.

                You raise some good points regarding testing and remote meets, and I am all for expanding drug testing in USAWA. I’m also not really picky about whether we call a meet postal or remote, so if postals give meet directors greater access to funds for drug testing, fine.

                I really like the Bench Press Heptathalon. Clark’s runs it in person with a remote option, High Country Vigour and other clubs gets together the same weekend as the in person meet, and I think we had 19 competitors last year. If the Heptathalon became a postal with an assigned weekend, it’s going to run pretty much exactly the same: Clark’s will get together at Clark’s, HCV will get together at HCV, etc. I don’t really care if it’s remote or postal, I just want to compete!

                I can’t speak to overall membership. I can say that I personally have wanted to get involved with all-around ever since I heard of it, and our little club out west couldn’t be as active as it is without the remote options. We’re still competing in person with each other and under the watchful eyes of certified officials.

                If testing is a concern, we need to make the consequences of popping a test more severe. It’s crazy to me that an athlete can get caught cheating and their records stay on the books. Cheaters should be stripped of all records and placings going back at least one year. Why worry about testing so much if the price of popping is just a slap on the wrist?

            Viewing 3 reply threads
            • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.